Q: An HR Manager overhears a group of employees discussing salaries in the cafeteria. In response, the HR Manager walks over to the employees’ table and tells them that employee pay is confidential, that employees are forbidden from discussing their salaries, and that if (s)he discovers that any of them has discussed personal pay with co-workers again, that employee will be disciplined and possibly terminated.The HR Manager returns to his/her office and drafts the following policy for inclusion in the employee handbook:
An employee’s pay is a private matter between you and the organization. The organization will keep this information in strictest confidence, and you are required to do the same. Violation of this policy will result in discipline, up to and including termination.
Can the organization get into legal trouble if the HR Manager terminates an employee for discussing salary with co-workers in the future? What if the organization includes the manager’s drafted policy in its employee handbook?